Antony Starr Won't Return as Homelander in Mortal Kombat 1

Antony Starr, best known for his chilling portrayal of Homelander in The Boys, has confirmed that he will not be lending his voice to the character in Mortal Kombat 1. His response was direct and left fans with mixed reactions. Below is a detailed look at how this news unfolded and what fans are saying.

Mortal Kombat 1’s Homelander Will Not Be Voiced by Antony Starr

Fans Are Disappointed At The News

During a recent interaction on Instagram, an enthusiastic fan asked Antony Starr if he would be voicing Homelander in Mortal Kombat 1. Starr responded bluntly with “nope,” dashing hopes of many who were eagerly anticipating his performance in the game.

When Mortal Kombat 1 revealed its upcoming DLC roster—including Homelander—excitement surged among fans of both the franchise and The Boys. Homelander, portrayed masterfully by Starr, is one of the most iconic antagonists in modern television. His complex mix of menace, charm, and unpredictability has made him a standout character, often credited as a major reason for The Boys' success. The popularity of the show even led to a spin-off, GenV, where Homelander makes appearances.

On November 12, 2023, Starr shared behind-the-scenes footage from GenV on Instagram. This prompted a curious comment asking about his involvement in Mortal Kombat 1. His reply? A simple, casual "nope."

Predictably, many fans expressed disappointment, especially considering how integral Starr’s performance has been to bringing the character to life.

Speculations Surrounding Antony Starr

This decision marks a notable contrast from the usual trend in the Mortal Kombat series, which often goes above and beyond to bring in original actors for their roles. For example, J.K. Simmons recently voiced Omni-Man in Mortal Kombat 1, reprising his role from the Invincible animated series. That move was widely praised, leading fans to expect the same level of authenticity with Homelander and Starr.

As a result, speculation has run rampant. Some believe Starr might be playing into Homelander's deceptive nature by giving a false answer. Others suspect he may be restricted from commenting due to a non-disclosure agreement. There are also those who think he simply wanted to end the recurring questions and gave a definitive answer to avoid further discussion.

Adding fuel to the fire, Starr did reprise his role as Homelander earlier this year for a Call of Duty collaboration in July. This proves he isn’t averse to voicing the character in gaming contexts. Given that precedent, many fans remain skeptical and hopeful that he might still appear in Mortal Kombat 1 in some capacity.

Only time will reveal whether Starr’s statement was final or just another twist in the ongoing narrative surrounding Homelander’s inclusion in Mortal Kombat 1. Until then, fans continue to speculate and await official word from NetherRealm Studios.